Efficiency Is Not the Point: Why the Defense Bar Must Use AI to Win, Not Just to Save
November 16, 2026
Most of the AI conversation in the defense bar has been about the billable hour: faster research, quicker drafting, cheaper medical summaries. Those gains are real, and client are right to seek them. But if efficiency is the whole strategy, we are missing the boat. The plaintiff bar is not using AI to save money. It is using AI to make money, and it is doing so at our client's expense.
The Plaintiff Bar Is Playing a Different Game
Plaintiff firms are adopting AI platforms built for one purpose: to increase claim value. Plaintiff vendors market demand packages, settlement valuation, negotiation preparation, and historical settlement intelligence drawn from hundreds of thousands of verdicts and settlements. Some of them claim settlement increases of up to 30%. Hundreds of millions of dollars in outside investment, much of it private equity, are funding the technology.
The tools go beyond the demand letter. Plaintiff firms are reportedly using AI to identify which claims are most likely to produce a runaway verdict, then concentrate money and personnel on them. Data-driven mock jury work is being used to sharpen themes before trial. And plaintiff lawyers, who compete fiercely for clients, share data and tactics across firms in ways the defense side rarely does.
The result is more persuasive narratives, more policy-limits pressure, and earlier time-limited demands, often before a liability investigation is complete. For a defense practice that handles bad faith and failure-to-settle exposure, that combination should get everyone's attendtion.
Expense Is the Smaller Number
"The Plaintiff Bar is Winning AI" makes a point that is worth repeating: legal expense is roughly 20% of total loss cost on litigated claims, yet most claims and defense technology has been aimed at that 20%. Indemnity is the larger number. If the plaintiff bar is using AI to move the indemnity number and we are using it only to trim the expense number, the math does not favor our clients.
What Outcome-Focused AI Looks Like on the Defense Side
Using AI for better outcomes means using it to generate insight and actionable advice, not just faster work product. In practice, that includes:
Data-driven valuation. Benchmark exposure by venue, injury, treatment pattern, and opposing counsel, rather than relying on gut instinct and anecdote.
Know the opponent. Analyze which plaintiff firms actually try cases, what verdicts have been obtained, and how they negotiate.
Sell our offers. The plaintiff bar has always sold its demands better than we sell our offers. AI can assemble the facts, medical-record gaps, causation weaknesses, and comparable outcomes into a defense evaluation as compelling as any demand package.
Early risk triage. Flag time-limited demands, policy-limits setups, and runaway-verdict indicators at intake, when there is till time to act.
Close the data gap. Defense firm data and claims-department data are often disconnected, unstructured, and inconsistent. Structured, shared data on demands, offers, and outcomes is the foundation for every other tool.
Carriers and Counsel Need to Move Together
Insurers bear the indemnity exposure but have largely left defense-side AI decisions to their panel firms. That should change. Carriers and defense counsel must jointly decide what outcome data to capture, which valuation and negotiation tools to vet, and how to measure success: not only lower defense spend, but better total claims outcomes. Sometimes that means investing more defense resources in a high-exposure claim not fewer.
The Bottom Line
The firms that will deliver real value to carriers and self-insureds are those using AI to answer the questions clients actually care about: What is the case worth? Who are we up against? When should we settle, and how do we prove our number? The plaintiff bar has already made that shift. The defense bar needs to catch up, and quickly.
Jim Pattillo is a leading litigation counsel for insurance, product, and commercial clients and is based in the firm's Birmingham, Alabama, office. Mr. Pattillo represents numerous commercial and personal insurers in matters involving bad faith, extra-contractual exposure, coverage litigation, and a variety of declaratory judgment actions. He also works closely with large SIU investigations on fraud-related matters. Mr. Pattillo focuses exclusively on litigation and trial work. He has a twenty-year trial record in the courtroom that is extensive and successful, including numerous seven and eight-figure exposures with results routinely exceeding client expectations.
About Christian & Small
Christian & Small LLP serves a diverse client base across Alabama, the Southeast, and nationwide, including individuals, closely held businesses, and Fortune 500 companies. By pairing highly experienced lawyers with clients' specific needs, Christian & Small delivers innovative, effective, and efficient solutions tailored to each client. With offices in Birmingham and Mobile, Alabama, and Jackson, Mississippi, Christian & Small specializes in litigation and business law and is a member of the International Society of Primerus Law Firms. Our corporate social responsibility initiatives focus on education, and diversity remains one of Christian & Small's core values.
No representation is made that the quality of legal services to be performed is greater than the quality of legal services performed by other lawyers.
GoAuto Insurance Company v. 2B Claims Services Inc. is an unpublished Eleventh Circuit decision that offers a practical lesson: an insurer cannot shift its own bad-faith risk-management decisions to an outside claims vendor. The case arose from a four-car accident with low policy limits and multiple potential claimants. Two claimants made a time-limited policy-limits demand requiring […]
Christian & Small is pleased to share that Kendall L. Fann has been named Outstanding Associate of the Year by Central Insurance. The award criteria include feedback from frontline adjusters, claims managers, and senior leadership on attorneys they believe have delivered superior service, upheld standards, and achieved results for the claims organization in keeping with […]
Partner Priscilla K. Williams Obtains Complete Defense Verdict of Insurance Client On May 19, 2020, while on vacation in Gulf Shores, the injured plaintiff was a front seat passenger in her friend’s vehicle that was rear-ended at a stop light. Despite Plaintiff’s testimony that the impact felt severe and she was projected forward, the evidence […]